Angelika Romero

Google review

I highly recommend making a stop at the fish house on your next trip to the Florida keys! The staff is so kind and very knowledgeable about the types of fish caught that same day. I ate Mahi mahi macambe and it was absolutely delicious! This dish is one of their most popular ones and I can see why: Very flavorful and I enjoyed the tomatoes and white wine sauce to top of the fish. I chose rice, beans as my side and this was also so good. For an appetizer, we tried the smoked fish dip and it is a must! If you cannot eat crackers like me because you have a gluten allergy, they can pair it with tortilla corn chips. Overall great experience here and very fresh!

Kolton Williams

Google review

This place was outstanding! I have celiac disease so I can appreciate that the menu items that are gluten free were clearly marked “GF” and they had some great options. Their conch chowder is GF and was awesome. To finish off our meal we had the GF brownie with vanilla ice cream. Everyone was very friendly and our meal came out very timely. I would highly recommend this place to anyone in the area. We will definitely be back!

Pat Hagen

Google review

The sad gluten free menu was a real disappointment. Poor descriptions of the food and no prices. The gf potato skins were nothing more than a baked potato with cheese and bacon served with dried out chives and diced tomatoes. $12.95 The gf French onion soup was good. $6.99 The conch chowder a rendition of tomato soup with presumably conch. $9.99 The server lacked any enthusiasm. The garden dining was delightful.

Lauren Fannon

Google review

Our waiter Aaron was very polite and helpful. Chef Floyd came out to visit us personally twice during dinner and was super friendly. He is very talented! After a couple years of having a house in the keys, this red tail snapper platter is my favorite meal of anywhere! I have a gluten and dairy allergy, and I can safely eat it baked. The spices are delicious! The view is great too. And they have live music! If you are a resident, you can join the Turtle Club for $25 and you get 15% off every visit plus 20 or 25% on Thursdays. It’s also dog friendly. We highly recommend! -Lauren and Andy.

Dovrat Donna Gotlib

Google review

My husband and I came because of the reviews about the vegan food and gluten free options…first I expected that the waitress that works there since they have these options, would actually understand the difference between gluten free and vegan…well she didn’t and had to run to the kitchen to ask after I insisted that the fact the salad was listed on the vegan menu didn’t mean it is gluten free especially that it had noodles listed in it. On the regular menu GF options were marked and on the vegan menu there were no markings for GF…my husband ordered the black bean burger and took two bites and didn’t like it because he said it was bitter… it came with fries so he ate the fries and didn’t find anything else to substitute it with… the burger came in a hoagie bun which is quite large…he took 2 bites and the manager said that he can’t remove it from the bill because he ate 1/2 of the sandwich!!! Horrible service! Not coming again even if they pay me!