Atly Logo

The 9 Best Gluten-Free Spots in Sayville

Gluten Free UsersGluten Free UsersGluten Free Users
40+

By Gluten Free Eats' gluten-free community

Updated Apr 2025

01
Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen

Gluten Free Icon

Celiac friendly

4836 Sunrise Hwy, Sayville, NY 11782, USA

BreakfastLunchCafeDeliveryTake AwayKid FriendlyPet FriendlyBrunchCeliac Friendly
Gluten Free Users
Gluten Free Users
Gluten Free Users
Learn more

Utterly obsessed with this place! It’s really hard to find a lunch spot that offers gluten free wraps so if you’re celiac like me, look no further! The food and coffee here are sooo good, it’s a must try 💓

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked
02
Cornucopia Health Foods

Cornucopia Health Foods

Gluten Free Icon

Accommodating

35 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782, USA

Delivery
Gluten Free Users
Gluten Free Users
Gluten Free Users
Learn more
03
Umberto's of Sayville

Umberto's of Sayville

Gluten Free Icon

Gluten-free options

37 N Main St, Sayville, NY 11782, USA

LunchDinnerVeganItalianPizzaDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingKid FriendlyVegetarianRestaurant
Gluten Free Users
Learn more
Profile Image
Declan O'Keefe

I had a really horrible experience here. They said a gluten free pizza would be ready in 15 minutes, but I ended up waiting an hour. What was really disappointing was that people who ordered ten, twenty, thirty minutes after we did got their pizza first. Some of these people even finished eating their pizzas before we got ours. Also, A gluten free pizza is 18 dollars! That's almost twice as much as what the pizzeria I usually go to charges. The staff said it was almost done but 20 minutes later it wasn't. The other customers were rude and took our seats because we were "waiting for too long". When I finally got it, they got the order wrong, because there was no pepperoni on mine. My friend got a regular one, and his one was extra cheese but the cheese was everywhere and it looked like a mess. After eating my stomach felt weird. I guess these "gluten free pies" probably have been exposed to gluten because the staff members don't change their gloves. Some of them didn't have gloves. My friend almost dropped his because the boxes are poorly designed. I used to like this place, but its clear they care about the money more than the experience of their customers. I wish this place respected their customers, guess I was wrong. Expensive, Lousy service, and bad food and environment.

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked
04
Sayville Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Sayville Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Gluten Free Icon

Gluten-free options

60 Main St, Sayville, NY 11782, USA

LunchDinnerItalianPizzaDeliveryTake AwayPet FriendlyOutdoor SeatingKid FriendlyOpen Late
Gluten Free Users
Gluten Free Users
Learn more
Profile Image
Kristina Farmer

Very accommodating about making a custom gluten free personal pie!

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked
05
Butera's

Butera's

Gluten Free Icon

Gluten-free options

100 S Main St #205, Sayville, NY 11782, USA

LunchDinnerItalianDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingKid FriendlyRestaurantBrunchPet Friendly
Gluten Free Users
Gluten Free Users
Learn more
Profile Image
Fran Pekor

The food was delicious. They make great gluten-free options. The service was great. Wonderful place!

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked