JohnB

Google review

We catered for 110 adults, plus 20 kids under 12. This was not the usual neighborhood pizzeria or bagel store catering. This was so much more for the same price. To start, some cousins couldn't have nightshade, some needed to be gluten free. All accommodated, no problem. We ordered chicken plicata. Delicious. It always is. Penne vodka too. We got eggplant rollatini. They hit it perfectly, great texture and flavor. Cylinder of ricotta mixture in the middle. The real star to me was the pulled pork. Even BBQ restaurants can present pulled pork that could have been Dinty Moore's. But this place makes pork that is not only flavorful but filled with bark. You can't just take a bite; you have to go back for more. This comes with perfectly presented sweet rolls, like Hawaiian rolls. Unfortunately, I was the host, and we provided take-out containers, so I missed some dishes. I did get a delicious hunk of the 5-foot sandwich, on tender Italian bread and stuffed thick with Italian cold cuts. We also got a five-foot bagel sandwich. We asked them to duplicate a roasted potato dish that the family's matriarch always made. They came back with a great dish rich with bacon and olive oil and crisp roasted potatoes. I also need to report on the seasonal bagels, shaped as a pumpkin with great pumpkin flavor. My family loves them!

Patrick Donnelly

Google review

They had a lot of Gluten free options & were knowledgeable about what is safe for people with Celiacs or Gluten sensitivity. Nice little shop. They also have tons of non gluten free stuff that looked awesome.

Rohanie Parbhoo

Google review

This place is legit. Their slices are amazing, they have gluten free options AND super friendly service. Absolutely recommend. 🙌🏽

Loretta Leistman

Google review

Tried to place an order for gluten-free pizza that my daughter-in-law orders from there frequently. Ever, who is the shift manager refused to make it. Canceled a large order and they didn’t even care. I was very happy Mary’s in Farmingdale was accommodating and cheaper.

Charles Marino

Google review

This is an excellent restaurant. I'm as much of a celiac as a person can possibly be, and their gluten free items have never made me sick. I take that to mean that they have a very clean kitchen.