Rochelle Claridge

Google review

Food is so good, staff is great and friendly! Plus gluten free options are always a bonus!

Anonymous Tips

Google review

Pizza pie Cafe is through and through a pizza buffet. There are a ton of different pizza flavors to choose from. Gluten options will cost extra though for those who may need to consider that. Loads of other different menu options are also available, such as a really solid salad bar, and even various pasta options. As is customary to most restaurants that charge for drinks, they do it shamelessly, as $2.99 for a soft serve drink is kind of steep even for the area especially. The pizza itself though is better than Little Caesars, but falls short somewhere before Pizza Hut and other various chains in terms of flavor for some of the pizzas. Highly recommend finishing off with some of the dessert pizzas, they are a worth while experience by itself. I have personally been to this location several times, the customer service experience is either rock solid or has some room for improvement, overall though, this is a great option for a pizza buffet eatery in the Rexburg Area. Edit: Added realtime pictures from last visit.

Nora Santana

Google review

My favorite restaurant in rexburg. Their sushi is amazing! The staff is wonderful and so kind. The food is so fresh and delicious but you are still eating healthy. Plus, they have gluten free and vegetarian options. There’s something for everyone here.

Justin Giles

Google review

When we said one was gluten free, they made sure to make it first! Highly recommend!

Britney McGinnis

Google review

Our family all loved our food. Huge portions. Gluten free options. My one huge disappointment was being quite surprised by automatic gratuity being added. We are good tippers and we're an average family of 5. To unexpectedly charge us 15% for gratuity at this casual dining restaurant was confusing.... And we were confused on if this goes to the server? Do we still tip on top. There was only one server for the whole place, she was great, food was fast. She was busy. So we either gave her the worst tip of 10% or a great tip of 25%. In the US custom is gratuity is used for larger parties, high end fine dining. It felt wrong to be unclear and NOT tip her. So we tipped more. Bringing our $80 meal to over $120 which was NOT what we had budgeted for our outing. So again, great place. Just disappointed and confused about this pay structure.