Top 21 Gluten-Free Pizzerias to Delight in Fort Myers
Your curated guide to gluten-free dining options, with detailed reviews and recommendations for safe celiac-friendly meals.
+157
Based on 160 recommendations
Last updated: June 22, 2025
Capone's Coal Fired Pizza
2225 First St, Fort Myers, FL 33901, USA
Accommodating Gluten-Free
PizzaDinnerPet FriendlyKid FriendlyOpen Late NightLunchOutdoor SeatingTake AwayVegetarian OptionsVegan OptionsCiderItalianDelivery
A unique combo of a lively atmosphere and interesting Al Capone memorabilia makes for a fun, entertaining spot to enjoy a meal.
People are saying
View more
Ms. Jade Alexis
First time I’m downtown Ft. Myers and I ordered the gluten free cheese pizza and it did NOT disappoint! I imagined being gluten free it would taste mediocre boy was I wrong. If I could give 10stars I would. The waitress however was lackluster. She got my drink order wrong. I asked for Mezcal and she brought me a glass of Moscato. After the mixup she advised Mezcal is only served on certain days 🤔. I ordered an Old fashioned and it was garbage. I waited 40 minutes for my food and only saw her 3 times. Once to take my drink order, once to take my food order and then to bring the check. It was a Thursday night and the tables were pretty empty so it wasn’t due to the crowd. I still would go again for the amazing tasting pizza and stick with a glass of wine! 🍕
A cozy hidden gem, this pizza spot offers an array of creative, authentic pies and quirky pizza-themed gifts, perfect for any pizza lover!
People are saying
View more
Todd Beaufort
This place has great pizza! We were in town for a short weekend and stumbled on this pizza because we were looking for a non-chain pizza place. Ended up going back again. The crust was great, lots of topping choices, gluten free options. The dining area is small but nice. Friendly staff.
A spacious spot with unique flavors, this place serves amazing dishes that keep everyone coming back for more, perfect for game days!
People are saying
View more
s kitchens
When the gluten-free pizza hit the table, I felt like I’d been sucker-punched by good intentions gone wrong. The crust wasn’t just bad—it was a culinary crime scene. Dull brown, spongy, and so undercooked it could’ve doubled as a prop in a zombie flick, it sat there under a blanket of melted cheese and toppings like a secret the kitchen was desperate to hide. If it weren’t for that cheese, stringy and forgiving, you’d swear this thing never saw the inside of an oven. I wanted to love it, I really did. But this crust? It’s the kind of thing that makes you question why you left the house.
With deliciously unique dough and a cozy atmosphere, this spot is perfect for families, offering games for kids and a pet-friendly vibe.
People are saying
View more
Vivian Reeves
Awesome spot, delicious pizza. Will definitely order again! The gluten free was a bit pricey ($17 or $18 for a 10”, compared to the other normal pizzas), but hey what can you do. I loved their red pizza sauce, so delicious! Only thing better would be if they can do keto/ pizza bowls or crustless pizza, then I bet I’d order weekly, lol! Definitely blew my carb count today!
Friendly people and great place to bring small kids to play while you enjoy a slice. Will certainly be getting take out from there again soon!
This spot serves up a customizable pizza experience with a fun vibe, crispy crust, and impressive customer service follow-up despite some hiccups.
People are saying
View more
James Murdock
I was here visiting family and had never heard of Blaze Pizza. I saw on Google that Blaze has a decent rating and the restaurant was close to where we were hanging out, so I decided to place a pickup order online. I ordered a large pepperoni and sausage, a large pepperoni and double cheese, a small gluten free mushroom, and cheese bread.
The restaurant seemed clean. My order was as ready when it was supposed to be. The staff was welcoming. When I got back to my family all of the food was still hot. The flavors were good (I tried all four items that I bought).
Upon looking at my receipt I noticed that I’d been charge a 15% tip which I didn’t know about and certainly didn’t authorize. I tip very well for good service when I dine in, and I am generous with delivery drivers, but I generally don’t tip if I’m picking up my order. I was shocked that a 15% tip would be added to an online order without the consent of the customer. At no point in the online ordering process was the addition of a tip noted.
I called the store for more than 20 minutes but no one answered. I made a complaint online.
The next day I received both an email and a phone call from a manager. They seemed to sincerely want to know what had gone wrong on their end. They were apologetic and compensated for their mistake.
Blaze Pizza certainly needs to address a couple of issues. First, no more automatically charging online customers a 15% tip that they did not initiate. Second, answer your phone.
BUT, I was impressed with their follow up. They won me back with their customer service. I’ll give them another try.
A cozy spot with a cute vibe, offering a standout menu that includes excellent pizza and unique options for everyone, perfect for takeout or a lunch date.
People are saying
View more
Lisa Fry
Finally found a great gluten-free pizza ! When I called and ordered ,they asked if it was an allergy and informed me of the kitchen and the glove change to make the gluten free pizza. I really appreciate the extra effort because you do not see it very often. Oh yea and the pizza was great!
I love their wings and they have the best Gluten free pizza in the Lehigh area. They are very quick as well and carryout is a breeze. Employees clearly are working hard!
Best gluten free pizza around. Love that they cook it in its own separate foil pan to prevent cross contamination. Amazing quality ingredients and always fresh!
We stopped in on an early afternoon, and there were a handful of people at the bar. Our bartenders were friendly and made us feel welcome. We split a gluten free pizza and it was very good.
A new gem in the neighborhood with delicious pizza and fresh salad, perfect for a casual and tasty meal!
People are saying
View more
J D
Recently discovered this neighborhood pizza spot! Just opened in January - new owners so don’t judge any reviews from over a year ago.
Delicious pizza & fresh salad!
Yummy Gluten free pizza option too (cauliflower crust) Will definitely be returning.
View menu
Poppy's Pizza
15501 Old McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33908, USA