Atly Logo

The 5 Best Gluten-Free Italian Restaurants in Brewster

Gluten Free UsersGluten Free UsersGluten Free Users
5+

By Gluten Free Eats' gluten-free community

Updated Apr 2025

01
Putnam Lake Pizza

Putnam Lake Pizza

Gluten Free Icon

Gluten-free options

65 Fairfield Dr, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

LunchDinnerItalianPizzaDeliveryTake AwayKid Friendly
Gluten Free Users
Learn more

Amazing pizza. I love the meat pizza and the Gluten Free is great too. We've tried it all over the area and they have the best GF pizza.

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked
02
Gaetano Pizza & Cafe

Gaetano Pizza & Cafe

Gluten Free Icon

Gluten-free options

100-B Independent Way, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

LunchDinnerItalianPizzaDeliveryTake AwayKid Friendly
Gluten Free Users
Learn more
Profile Image
Gary Zimmerman

Gluten free pizza is served here and its very good.

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked
03
Mezza Luna Pizzeria & Restaurant

Mezza Luna Pizzeria & Restaurant

Gluten Free Icon

Gluten-free options

1507 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

LunchDinnerBrunchItalianDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingKid FriendlyPet Friendly
Gluten Free Users
Learn more
Profile Image
Carmine Lamanna

Not sure what happened to my last review for this incredible restaurant. My gluten free shrimp scampi was amazing. Chris was our server and truly a standout. We saw him for tonight, our second visit, and he stopped for a moment to chat. He is so welcoming and an asset to this restaurant. We love our new neighborhood restaurant and look forward to many visits …

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked
04
Aversano's Restaurant - Catering - Pizzeria

Aversano's Restaurant - Catering - Pizzeria

Gluten Free Icon

Gluten-free options

CCHF+9Q Sears Corners, Brewster, NY, USA

LunchDinnerBrunchItalianDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingKid Friendly
Gluten Free Users
Learn more
Profile Image
Carmine Lamanna

The meal started with great drinks. It was busy but we had to wait for water. 15 minutes into the time we arrived. I asked for gluten free pasta with my gluten free meal. I looked over and saw generous portions of meals with pasta. My meal arrived - chicken franchise with a side of pasta in a large bowl with red sauce. I. asked for franchise gluten free sauce. The original bowl was large. After 20 minutes, the scant portion of pasta arrived in a finger bowl! It was absolutely inedible.- the pasta was undercooked and had a sauce that tasted like oil and grease. . One of the 5 servers offered desert , as a compensation, which clearly I can’t eat.. . Nice but inappropriate for my dietary concerns. I would suggest they either understand gluten free, including celiac disease, or just don’t cater to this population. I left hungry and disappointed.

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked
05
Zegarelli’s Restaurant Bar Pizza & Catering

Zegarelli’s Restaurant Bar Pizza & Catering

Gluten Free Icon

Gluten-free options

185 Fairfield Dr, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

LunchDinnerBrunchOpen LateItalianCocktailsPizzaDeliveryTake AwayOutdoor SeatingKid Friendly
Gluten Free Users
Learn more
Profile Image
Charles M

Mainstay of local restaurants. Consistent, quality food preparation. Excellent, quality pizza and entrees. Gluten free options are also available. Great parking access.

Gluten Free Menu Icon
GF options marked