Kristen M

Google review

Can’t say enough positive things about this place ! We were a party of 7- got seated easily by pleasant hostess. Our waitress, Kristen was pleasant and really good. They have a separate cooking area for this with gluten allergy. Had a mix of sweet and savory options. Food was fresh and delicious! We will definitely be back! And we just found they are opening a new one! Keep it up Buttermilk staff and owners!

Caitlin Bushelon

Google review

I placed an online order for pick up. When I went to pick up the order I noticed that none of the condiments or utensils were in the bag. After waiting 20 minutes for someone to help me, I finally called to someone behind the bar and asked for the items missing. The girl that helped me, had a look on her face like I was the most annoying person ever. She also proceeded to explain that orders are only supposed to come with one piece of condiment each. I told her, "well, I paid extra to get more in the app." She just huffed and walked away. When I got home, I realized that half the order was still missing. There was no sausage that is supposed to come with the pancakes. And I paid extra for gluten free toast, which was not in it either. I feel like I always have an issue when picking up orders from here. Edit to the management having read this: I also realized the pancakes were wrong. I decided to call the restaurant at this point. He told me that he wished I had called the restaurant before writing a review. We'll, I wish that my order hadn't been so screwed up!!

Kimberly M

Google review

Drinks amazing, food amazing, what more could you ask for? Went at 5:30 on a Friday and it was pretty empty but by 6-6:30 they were packed. The gluten free options are phenomenal, definitely obsessed over the fried goat cheese! Everything tasted so fresh, even the cocktails. We'll definitely come back, hoping they open another location in Nassau!

Lacey Donlon

Google review

It's unfortunate I'm leaving this review, I really like their gluten free bagels and the fact there is a place to finally get gluten free bagels because I'm celiac. Over the past few years, everytime I get a bagel with cream cheese there is literally like a smear of cream cheese on it, practically nothing. I worked in a bagel place and the rule always was give a little extra they can always take it off. You don't want a customer upset because there isn't enough. I'm already paying extra for gluten free, but then to get practically no cream cheese on the bagels every time is really disappointing. I have pictures but there is no option to add them.

Barbara Long Bonilla

Google review

First, I want to say that I intend to give this place another try, since the food was delicious and the servers were very nice... however, they got my takeout order wrong and put chicken on my vegetarian gluten free quesadillas, which If I had dined in, I could have just sent it back to the kitchen. The server taking the order specifically asked if my gluten free order was without chicken, which I confirmed. As it was, I had stopped there on my way home from work and didn't want to drive another half hour back there just to exchange my food. My son did enjoy his food, I want to add. I think I will go back there some time to order in. Someone with food sensitivities should probably avoid getting food to go from here unless you have time to take your order apart and inspect it first. This is why I gave it only 3 stars. If you have no dietary restrictions, add another star. UPDATE: I came back and had dinner here with my husband and had a most enjoyable meal. He had the cuban sandwich, which was done to perfection. I had my gluten-free cheese quesadillas which were perfect. The staff are all friendly and attentive. We loved the neighborhood vibe and will be making Tiesto's a regular stop.