Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for cool Sicilian pizza to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 727 Reviews
+724
User
User
User
Updated
01
Concrete Sicilian Eatery image 1
Concrete Sicilian Eatery image 2
Concrete Sicilian Eatery image 3
View all
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ›‹๏ธ Cozy
๐Ÿฝ๏ธ Dinner Spots
More

Open, spacious dining area with high ceilings and modern decor creates a cozy yet chic atmosphere. Live music on a dedicated stage adds to the inviting, relaxed vibe. The space features beautiful artwork and ambient lighting, blending rustic and stylish elements.

People are saying

"The food here is really good, especially the carbonara."

"I enjoyed chatting with the cool owners."

"The place has a cool, cozy vibe."

Good to know

1

Live jazz is available every Wednesday night.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

3

Reservations are available through Resy for guaranteed seating.

02
Leonardoโ€™s Pizza - Sunnyside, Queens. image 1
Leonardoโ€™s Pizza - Sunnyside, Queens. image 2
Leonardoโ€™s Pizza - Sunnyside, Queens. image 3
View all
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza
๐Ÿ’Ž Hidden Gems
More

Renovated space combines exposed brick and clean benches with a classic New York slice vibe. Warm, homey atmosphere feels like a neighborhood pizzeria with a contemporary old-school touch. TVs often show games, adding casual energy to the setting.

People are saying

"I think this place has the best pizza here."

"The pizza here is always fresh and tastes amazing."

"This place feels welcoming and looks really clean."

Good to know

1

Garlic knots are only available on GrubHub and DoorDash.

2

The classic slice does not use sweet pizza sauce.

3

Prices start at $10 for a pizza.

03
Traditas Pizza image 1
Traditas Pizza image 2
Traditas Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ• White Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza Slices
More

Pizza restaurant offers cozy yet modern interior with inviting outdoor seating that captures a lively city vibe. Atmosphere stays relaxed and clean, suitable for casual or special occasions. Space includes ample seating inside and out, supporting both groups and solo diners.

People are saying

"The pizza here tastes great and feels authentic."

"I love the crispy crust and tasty pizza options."

Good to know

1

The prices are fair, likely the cheapest regular slice in NYC.

2

Lunchtime from 12-2 can be very busy; arrive early for a seat.

3

Hawaiian pizza often sells out quickly.

04
ANDIAMO PIZZA image 1
ANDIAMO PIZZA image 2
ANDIAMO PIZZA image 3
View all

ANDIAMO PIZZA

๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐ŸŒ™ Late Night Spot
๐Ÿ• Pizza Slices
More

Small space with six tables and counter seating offers a cozy atmosphere with bright lighting and calming background music. Friendly staff create a welcoming vibe, making it ideal for a quick, satisfying meal. The place stands out for its gluten-free pizza options and large, tasty slices.

People are saying

"The atmosphere here is really cool and great."

"It's just a really cool spot."

"I love how cool and friendly it feels."

Good to know

1

You can grab a single slice, making it super convenient.

2

ANDIAMO PIZZA is open late at night, perfect after clubbing.

3

The prices are affordable, making it a budget-friendly option.

05
Nuovo York Pizza image 1
Nuovo York Pizza image 2
Nuovo York Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Thin Crust Pizza
More

Classic New Yorkโ€“style pizza restaurant with spacious, inviting atmosphere and clean, modern design. Music curated by the chef adds a unique vibe, while seating encourages easy conversation. Street view offers a perfect spot for people watching.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious, fresh pizza here."

"This place has a cool vibe."

"The people working here are super cool."

Good to know

1

Nuovo is open until 3 AM on a Monday.

2

The deal of 2 slices with toppings and a soda for $10 is unmatched in Manhattan pizza places.

3

A slice is huge and costs about $4.

06
Tours of NYC image 1
Tours of NYC image 2
Tours of NYC image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐ŸŽ‰ Fun Activities
๐Ÿค” Interesting
More

Food tours offer authentic local flavors like thick Sicilian pizza with rich crusts and balanced toppings. Guides add live music and share hidden historical facts, creating a lively vibe. Stops include ghost spots and cozy places, blending cool history with tasty bites.

People are saying

"I had a fun tour full of interesting stories."

"The food we tried was delicious and filling."

"I loved learning about the city's ghost and gangster past."

Good to know

1

The tour offers a mix of culture, history, and food.

2

Expect a relaxed pace with no rush during the tour.

3

Reservations are recommended to secure a spot on the tour.

07
Traditas Pizza image 1
Traditas Pizza image 2
Traditas Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ• Margherita Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza Slices
More

Pizza restaurant offers a cozy, lively atmosphere with an authentic Italian vibe and fire house music. The space feels like an in-restaurant extravaganza, emphasizing quality over formality. Guests often relax inside, enjoying the comfortable, immaculate setup.

People are saying

"The pizza here is tasty and always hits the spot."

"I highly recommend trying their pizza to everyone."

"The lasagna pizza is amazing and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open after midnight on Fridays.

2

Three slices, garlic knots, a bottle of water, and a Coke cost less than $25.

3

The Chicken Parmesan slice costs about $6, while the plain/cheese slice is $4.

08
Nolita Pizza image 1
Nolita Pizza image 2
Nolita Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza Slices
More

Small pizzeria offers square Sicilian slices with homemade marinara and New York style options. DJ Barry's music fuels a lively atmosphere that feels authentic and relaxed. Seating is limited but the minimalist design keeps the vibe cool and engaging.

People are saying

"I loved the vibe and the pizza here."

"The pizza is always fresh and tastes amazing."

"The staff are super friendly and make you feel at home."

Good to know

1

Pizza is available until 2am on weekends.

2

The restaurant is inexpensive, making it a budget-friendly option.

3

You can get free drinks if you order a whole pie.

09
Vito's Slices and Ices image 1
Vito's Slices and Ices image 2
Vito's Slices and Ices image 3
View all
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿ• New York Style Pizza
๐Ÿ• Pizza
More

Small pizza spot with limited seating and a vintage retro vibe featuring brick walls and Italian flag colors. Atmosphere feels authentic and nostalgic, lively with great music and a busy street view. Offers a classic New York-style experience with quick service and a welcoming energy.

People are saying

"The Sicilian pizza has a great crunch and flavor."

"The place has a cool retro vibe with chill people."

"It's a cool old school pizza place."

Good to know

1

This spot is a popular choice for lunch during New York Comic Con.

2

The garlic knots cost $2.75 for 3.

3

Ordering to eating took a maximum of 3 minutes.

10
Upside Pizza image 1
Upside Pizza image 2
Upside Pizza image 3
View all
๐Ÿ˜Ž Cool
๐Ÿ• Sicilian Pizza
๐Ÿž Sourdough
๐Ÿ• Pizza
More

Shiny, new pizza spot with classic New York charm and loud techno music creating a lively but intense atmosphere. Pizza features crispy chewy crusts and standout spicy vodka sauce, though slices tend to be small and greasy. Outdoor seating is available but requires some upkeep.

Good to know

1

Slices cost $5 each, which may be considered expensive by some.

2

There was no line at the pizzeria during my visit.

3

Upside Pizza is convenient for students looking for a quick meal.