Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for cookies and cream with New York cheesecake in New York City

Based on 948 Reviews
+945
User
User
User
Updated
01
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Buttercup BakeShop image 2
Buttercup BakeShop image 3
View all
🍪 Cookies And Cream
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🍮 Pudding
🛋️ Cozy
More

Small cupcake shop with classic, old school design and pink, cute interior creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Soft jazz music plays while two small tables offer seating for quick treats. Known for outstanding cupcakes and unique flavors like banana cream pie and red velvet cheesecake.

People are saying

"The Cookies and Cream cupcake is light, soft, and tastes amazing."

"The cookies and cream cupcakes taste so moist and sweet."

"I tried a bunch of cupcakes, including cookies and cream."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

02
Eileen's Special Cheesecake image 1
Eileen's Special Cheesecake image 2
Eileen's Special Cheesecake image 3
View all
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🍪 Cookies And Cream
🍯 Caramel
🍫 Chocolate Mousse
More

Small bakery offers light, airy New York cheesecake and a best-selling cookies and cream flavor. Space is cozy and busy, with limited seating mostly at a counter. Cheesecakes are rich yet not too sweet, perfect for quick enjoyment.

People are saying

"I found the best New York cheesecake I ever had here."

"Eileen's serves the real classic New York cheesecake."

"The Cookies and Cream cheesecake is so creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

The shop is small and has no seating, so you will probably have to take your order to go.

2

Each cheesecake is freshly homemade on-site.

3

The prices are very expensive for non-New Yorkers in relation to the size.

03
Junior's Restaurant and Bakery image 1
Junior's Restaurant and Bakery image 2
Junior's Restaurant and Bakery image 3
View all

Junior's Restaurant and Bakery

🍪 Cookies And Cream
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🤩 Lively
🕹️ Retro
More

Space combines retro diner vibe with vibrant decor featuring red and yellow hues. Atmosphere stays fun and lively, often busy and chaotic, with music that is pleasant and not overpowering. Crowd enjoys classic American comfort with standout cheesecake and a bar offering notable cocktails and beers.

People are saying

"The place has a lively vibe and tasty, big portions."

"The New York cheesecake is moist, creamy, and delicious."

"I love the classic New York cheesecake here."

Good to know

1

You can put your name on a waitlist to plan your visit better.

2

The place is busy and open till midnight, close to Times Square.

3

On Saturday night at 6:00 PM, there was a 10-minute wait for a table for two.

04
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 2
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 3
View all
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🍪 Cookies And Cream
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍰 Layer Cake
More

Bakery offers cozy indoor seating and a quiet backyard garden with beautiful lighting for a relaxed atmosphere. Space feels crowded and noisy inside, with tables placed closely together. Outdoor area provides a calm spot to enjoy desserts and drinks away from the bustle.

People are saying

"It's a cozy spot with lots of yummy treats to choose from."

"The cakes and desserts here taste fresh and delicious."

"The atmosphere feels warm and welcoming here."

Good to know

1

Mia's is open until midnight on weekends and 10 PM on weeknights.

2

Expect a 15-minute wait for to-go desserts during peak hours.

3

Parking near the bakery is challenging, with limited metered spaces.

05
Grace Street Coffee & Desserts image 1
Grace Street Coffee & Desserts image 2
Grace Street Coffee & Desserts image 3
View all
🍪 Cookies And Cream
🍰 New York Cheesecake
😎 Chill
🤙 Casual
More

Loud, crowded space with high noise levels and self-service setup shapes the experience. Seating is roomy but uncomfortable, with bare, peeling walls giving an unfinished feel. Energy stays lively, making calm conversation difficult.

People are saying

"The desserts taste great but it gets crowded and loud."

"I love the vibe and the desserts are always amazing."

"The basque burnt cheesecake is rich and perfect to share."

Good to know

1

You need to order at the front entrance counter.

2

Expect to spend almost $20 per person for a full dessert.

3

There is no way to reserve a table at this place.

06
Brooklyn Diner image 1
Brooklyn Diner image 2
Brooklyn Diner image 3
View all
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🍪 Cookies And Cream
🛋️ Cozy
🍟 Diner
More

Large, bright diner with traditional New York decor and retro exterior creates an authentic vibe. Atmosphere feels lively and celebrity-infused, with comfortable seating and booths ideal for people watching. Design uses shutters and mirrors to avoid feeling cramped, distinguishing it from typical NYC diners.

People are saying

"I enjoy the classic diner vibe and lively spot."

"The food tasted good but felt small and pricey."

"I love their burgers and pastrami sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served all day.

2

The restaurant closes at 9:00 p.m.

3

Reservations are needed for this diner.

07
Crumbl image 1
Crumbl image 2
Crumbl image 3
View all
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🍪 Cookies And Cream
Unique
🍪 Cookie
More

Small, crowded spot with exposed cookie-making and loud music sets a lively mood. Cookies and cream Oreo Cake offers rich flavor, while the New York cheesecake cookie tastes great but costs more. Self-service screens and limited outdoor seating keep things quick and modern.

People are saying

"The place was crowded but ordering was easy and quick."

"The cookies were tasty but the selection was limited."

"I thought these cookies were the best I've had."

Good to know

1

The free cookie promotion is often inconsistent; check availability before visiting.

2

Expect a 20-minute wait for the free cookie promotion during peak hours.

3

The best time to visit for the free cookie is between 8 AM and 10 AM.

08
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 1
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 2
Van Leeuwen Ice Cream image 3
View all
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🍪 Cookies And Cream
🌰 Pistachio
🍦 Ice Cream
More

Small, tight space with no seating creates a quick, casual vibe. Calm and classy atmosphere with an uplifting aroma fills the air. Offers a wide variety of vegan flavors and is known for exceptional ice cream quality.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors are delicious and unique."

"This ice cream place is a must-try and very popular."

"I found the vegan Cookies and Cream ice cream to be delicious."

Good to know

1

The store doesn't accept cash, only credit or other forms of e-money.

2

Expect long wait times, especially after Broadway shows end.

3

There isn't anywhere to sit down at this location.

09
Sugar Factory New York - Time Square image 1
Sugar Factory New York - Time Square image 2
Sugar Factory New York - Time Square image 3
View all
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🍪 Cookies And Cream
🤩 Lively
🎉 Fun Activities
More

Restaurant offers upstairs and downstairs bars with loud music and a fun atmosphere suited for celebrations. Maximalist desserts and cocktail variety stand out amid a space with worn decor and mixed cleanliness impressions.

People are saying

"The food was good but the vibe was hit or miss."

"I loved the fun vibe and great food here."

"They always add a big automatic tip to the bill."

Good to know

1

Lunch is served after 3:30 PM.

2

A mandatory 20% service fee is added to every bill.

3

The restaurant has no parking available.

10
NY Bakery and Desserts Midtown image 1
NY Bakery and Desserts Midtown image 2
NY Bakery and Desserts Midtown image 3
View all
🍪 Cookies And Cream
🍰 New York Cheesecake
🌙 Late Night Spot
🍨 Desserts
More

Bright, cozy bakery with beautiful decor and a flowing chocolate fountain creates a friendly atmosphere. Seating includes a small back area and outdoor options, offering a comfortable place to enjoy a wide array of desserts. The vibe is inviting and the space feels clean and well-appointed.

People are saying

"The desserts taste great and there’s plenty to choose from."

"The New York Cheesecake is delicious and creamy."

"I think this is the best New York cheesecake ever."

Good to know

1

The establishment is open 24 hours for late-night cravings.

2

Cheesecakes and desserts are available late at night.

3

No vegan options are available for those with dietary restrictions.