Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for key lime pie and cookies to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 727 Reviews
+724
User
User
User
Updated
01
ByClio Bakery image 1
ByClio Bakery image 2
ByClio Bakery image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🍰 Chocolate Cake
🍫 Chocolate
More

Bakery offers a cozy, intimate space with natural light flooding through large windows and a quiet, welcoming atmosphere. Seating areas invite guests to relax with treats and coffee while watching staff bake. Elegant presentation and unique flavor profiles distinguish the cakes and pastries.

People are saying

"This cake's flavor is perfect and not too sweet."

"I love their unique cookies like tandoori masala and Turkish coffee."

"The cookies and cakes here are creative and delicious."

Good to know

1

No restroom is available for customers, so plan ahead.

2

The price of a slice of specialty cake is $12.

3

You can get a whole cake for any special occasion.

02
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 1
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 2
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🍧 Sorbet
🍮 Pudding
More

Vibrant ice cream shop offers refreshing key lime pie gelato and standout Amaretti cookies with unique texture. Family- and vegan-friendly space features original Harlem murals and comfy seating for work or socializing.

People are saying

"I love how their gelato flavors always surprise me."

"The chocolate chip cookies here are fresh and hand-made."

"I love their cookies and cream gelato and fresh cookies."

Good to know

1

They offer a 10% discount for students, teachers, and first responders.

2

To get the college student discount, you need to print your ID card.

3

Gelatos from the day before are discounted.

03
Petit Chou image 1
Petit Chou image 2
Petit Chou image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🎂 Cheesecake
🍰 Cream Puffs
More

Tiny bakery with cozy seating and modern design offers beautiful, artful pastries that capture authentic French flavors. Atmosphere feels lively and charming, drawing people who appreciate quality and visual appeal in desserts.

People are saying

"I thought their chocolate chip cookie was gooey and crisp."

"The chocolate chip cookie is thick, gooey, and delicious."

"I tried several pastries, including the chocolate chip cookie."

Good to know

1

Make sure to check in during the holidays for unique offers that often require orders in advance.

2

The pastries contain fish gelatin, which is important for people with allergies or dietary restrictions.

3

They have limited indoor seating, so prepare to take your order to go.

04
La Cheesecake Bake Shop image 1
La Cheesecake Bake Shop image 2
La Cheesecake Bake Shop image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🎂 Cheesecake
🥧 Pie
More

Small bakery offers a welcoming atmosphere with homemade desserts and reasonable prices. Cheesecake and rainbow cookies stand out as the best-tasting treats, drawing steady crowds and occasional long lines. Walls feature humorous stickers, adding a unique touch to the cozy space.

People are saying

"I considered their rainbow cookies amazing."

"The rainbow cookies have the best almond flavor and fluffy texture."

"I like the assorted Italian and black and white cookies."

Good to know

1

This place is cash only.

2

During holiday rush orders, expect 1 to 2 hour waits if the line is out the door.

3

Get there early as there will certainly be a line and people can wait for an hour.

05
O'Toole's Way image 1
O'Toole's Way image 2
O'Toole's Way image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🍽️ Lunch Spot
🤩 Lively
More

Irish bar with live music and modern sleek bars offers a warm, lively atmosphere. Outdoor seating under an elevated park creates a quiet, charming space. TVs are well-placed for viewing sports without channel changes.

People are saying

"The place has a warm vibe with great music."

"I'd visit again if I'm nearby."

Good to know

1

Customers must order dinner food before being seated.

2

Outdoor seating is available for lunch.

3

The place sometimes gets busy and has a wait.

06
Seoul BAP image 1
Seoul BAP image 2
Seoul BAP image 3
View all
🍪 Cookie
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍽️ Dinner Spots
🍖 Ribs
More

Gastropub combines modern elegance with cozy warmth in a space featuring a sleek bar up front and a larger area with a big screen TV in the back. Atmosphere stays relaxed and intimate with friendly bartenders and inviting lighting. The setup accommodates families and larger parties, making it suitable for casual gatherings or events.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and creative Korean dishes here."

"The cocktails here are amazing and beautifully made."

"The short ribs and sliders are absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant can get busy.

2

The back area is ideal for happy hour or cocktail parties.

3

Expect to pay $5 for a small plate of kimchi.

07
Crumbl image 1
Crumbl image 2
Crumbl image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🍨 Desserts
🍫 Chocolate
More

Cookie factory shines with fresh baked aroma and warm, soft cookies that taste amazing. Key Lime Pie offers a distinctive flavor that stands out. Small, clean shop with Instagrammable pink tones keeps a calm, chill vibe despite crowds.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and delicious."

"I love trying the new cookie flavors every week."

"I think these cookies are the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The kiosk does not accept cash; bring a card for purchases.

2

A box of 4 cookies costs $17.99.

3

The menu changes every week, with new cookies every Monday.

08
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 2
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🍰 Birthday Cake
🚫🌾 Gluten Free
More

Cozy bakery offers a warm vibe with rustic wooden accents and comfy seating. Key lime pie shines with a perfect tart-sweet mix, while almond cookies cater well to gluten-free diets. Desserts like coconut cake and hazelnut cookies add tasty variety.

People are saying

"I loved the fresh and delicious hazelnut cookie."

"The rainbow cookies and cakes are so good here."

"I love the almond cookies but not the peanut butter ones."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for custom cake orders, especially for weekends.

2

The bakery offers a variety of gluten-free and vegan options.

3

Cakes are prepared in advance and may not be freshly baked.

09
Peacefood image 1
Peacefood image 2
Peacefood image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🥧 Pie
🌱 Vegan Friendly
More

Spacious vegan restaurant with gorgeous decor and collectible art on the walls creates an elegant but casual atmosphere. Warm lighting and jazz covers set a relaxing, peaceful vibe. Staff contribute to a friendly, inviting environment that feels both serene and airy.

People are saying

"The double chocolate cookie was spectacular."

"Some cookies were amazing, others felt stale."

"The key lime pie tastes amazing and feels smooth."

Good to know

1

Peacefood is BYOB, but drinks must be kosher.

2

Reservations are recommended as walk-in availability is limited.

3

The restaurant is kosher, catering to dietary restrictions.

10
Little Pie Company image 1
Little Pie Company image 2
Little Pie Company image 3
View all
🥧 Key Lime Pie
🍪 Cookie
🎂 Cheesecake
🥧 Pie
More

Open kitchen reveals bakers crafting pies, filling the air with buttery pastry aroma. Small, cozy space offers outdoor shaded seating and a homey atmosphere. Constant flow of people creates a pleasant, relaxed vibe.

People are saying

"This key lime pie is the best I've ever had."

"The key lime pie hits the perfect sweet and tart spot."

"I loved their housemade cookies and cakes; they were mega delicious."

Good to know

1

Little Pie Co offers 50% off select pies at 7 PM daily.

2

Pre-order pies for holidays like Thanksgiving to ensure availability.

3

Expect high prices; pies can cost around $64 each.