Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
New York's best

Cool consignment shops

Browsing consignment racks is about finding pieces that carry a history and a style all their own.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
HypeClub image 1
HypeClub image 2
HypeClub image 3
View all
Shoe store

Open layout with organized browsing and clean, authentic sneakers creates a welcoming, cozy vibe. Calming music and friendly energy make the space feel comfortable and focused. The store stands out for its exclusive sneaker selection and neat, well-kept environment.

The store offers a collection of cool shoes including a nice selection of pre-loved Jordans. Sellers and people there are consistently super cool, creating a very cool vibe overall.

People are saying

"The staff at this footwear store are so friendly and helpful."

"I found a huge selection of authentic shoes here."

"I found the shop to be really cool with a great selection."

Good to know

1

The store sells a wide range of hard-to-find sneakers.

2

The store offers a lifetime authenticity guarantee on all sneakers.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted for purchases.

02
Mr Goods Buy & Sell image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop shines with great deals and a well-organized layout. Owner "A" adds a super cool vibe that matches the unique streetwear on offer. Atmosphere blends luxury with hypebeast culture, making it a favorite downtown spot.

Offers great consignment options with prices better than other shops. Stands out as a favorite consignment spot downtown with consistently good deals.

Owner "A" brings a super cool vibe and is worth asking for. The spot offers cool streetwear and unique items that stand out.

People are saying

"The staff here is knowledgeable about luxurious items and attentive to your needs."

"Oleg was a cool and helpful person."

"Ahmed made my consignment experience professional, knowledgeable, and trustworthy."

Good to know

1

All items at Mr. Goods are authentic and high quality.

2

You can receive cash on the same day for your sold items.

3

Transactions are priced and negotiated quickly.

03
Coclico NOLITA image 1
Shoe store

Store showcases unique, timeless styles with impeccable craftsmanship and exceptional comfort. Shoes feature high-quality materials that balance beauty, sustainability, and durability. Atmosphere reflects a gorgeous, well-curated space with a reputation for excellence.

People are saying

"This footwear store has beautiful, well-made shoes with timeless styles."

"These shoes are comfortable all day, even on city streets."

"The customer service here is prompt and helpful."

Good to know

1

Coclico shoes are known for their exceptional quality and comfort.

2

The store offers a unique selection of stylish and sustainable footwear.

3

Coclico shoes are re-soleable, extending their lifespan.

04
aptiques Modern image 1
Consignment shop

Boutique consignment shop with thoughtfully curated vintage bags, unique collectibles, and designer pieces. Atmosphere feels like a local favorite filled with high-quality, rare items that invite browsing and discovery. Owner's expert knowledge adds depth to the shopping experience.

People are saying

"You'll find unique treasures you instantly fall in love with."

"The vintage here is run by passionate, knowledgeable people with exquisite taste."

"The owner's depth of knowledge is really interesting."

Good to know

1

The store offers a carefully curated selection of vintage and rare pieces.

2

Expect to find unique antiques and collectibles that are hard to find elsewhere.

3

The owner is knowledgeable about the history and stories behind the items.

05
Good Hands Drum Shop image 1
Musical instrument store

Drum shop combines clubhouse, studio, and library vibes with two rooms for gear testing. Atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, attracting both beginners and experienced drummers. Offers a wide selection of vintage and new drums, including rare and authentic gear.

Good to know

1

The shop offers a great selection of used and vintage gear.

2

Jess Birch, the owner, is an expert in drums and cymbals.

3

There is a continuous influx of merchandise, making every visit exciting.

06
Flute Center image 1
Musical instrument store

Musical instrument store offers an immense selection of flutes and comfortable practice rooms. Staff are all flutists, providing professional, friendly service with an on-site repair team for quick adjustments. The space feels high-end and welcoming, supporting both novices and professionals.

People are saying

"The staff's warmth and kindness make it feel Kid Friendly."

"Kristen made me feel comfortable and welcome."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide range of flutes for all skill levels.

2

Try out flutes in-store before making a purchase.

3

Expert staff is available to provide guidance and recommendations.

07
Crossroads Trading image 1
Used clothing store

Used clothing store with organized layout and clothes sorted by size and type. Atmosphere feels friendly with a clean, well-lit space and plenty of mirrors and dressing rooms. Offers a wide selection from basics to vintage designer items at affordable prices.

Most items brought in go through consignment quickly thanks to efficient processing. The exact details of the consignment process or its availability at Crossroads Trading remain unclear.

Employees are super nice and the clothes are clean, organized, and cool. Staff try to appear cool, which affects the vibe.

People are saying

"The staff here for women's clothing are so helpful and chill."

"The people here are so sweet and helpful with vintage finds."

"I found brand new or barely worn shoes for a steal."

Good to know

1

The store offers a range of products at thrift and vintage prices.

2

The store accepts a variety of clothing types including vintage, high-end designer, and everyday streetwear.

3

The prices at the store are fair.

08
Tokyo Joe NYC image 1
Consignment shop

Small, curated shop offers high-end vintage clothing with reasonable prices and unique designer pieces. Intimate and charming atmosphere features well-organized racks showcasing dresses, coats, bags, and men's items. The vibe is cool and refreshing, standing out from pricier, pretentious vintage stores nearby.

Offers a cute vibe with lower prices compared to many other consignments nearby.

The shop has a cool vibe with some awesome finds. The staff is super cool and approachable.

People are saying

"I thought this vintage shop was the best in the neighborhood."

"I found the prices at this thrift store to be extremely reasonable."

"I thought this was the best vintage store in the neighborhood."

Good to know

1

They accept vintage, mid-range brands, and designer items for consignment.

2

They pay out 50% for consigned items.

3

They always have unique bags and shoes.

09
The RealReal image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop offers a spacious layout with a curated selection of pre-owned luxury and designer items. Atmosphere combines a downtown vibe with organized, elegant displays that highlight vintage and current trends. Shoppers find a mix of hard-to-find pieces and discounted designer goods in a lively, flea market-like setting.

The consignment process is clear and easy to follow with staff explaining each step in detail. The team is friendly and helpful, making appointments seamless and welcoming consignments with a smile.

Downtown vibe feels cool and lively. The doorman wears cool glasses and shows more kindness than the staff. The concept behind The RealReal stands out as very cool.

People are saying

"The staff here makes luxury shopping feel approachable and personal."

"The staff here helps you find incredible fashion for women's clothing."

"Sean made the consignment process so easy and comfortable."

Good to know

1

Items discounted over 40% at TheRealReal are non-returnable.

2

Everything at TheRealReal is authenticated for peace of mind.

3

The prices for second-hand luxury items are the best compared to online and in-store options.

10
Tokio 7 image 1
Consignment shop

Curated selection of high-end luxury and vintage clothing fills a larger-than-expected space with a busy thrift store atmosphere and cool vibes. Crowds seek designer pieces blending modern Asian streetwear and classic styles, with prices reflecting brand and condition. Storefront features a distinctive scrap metal Predator sculpture, adding to its unique character.

The consignment process is straightforward and easy to navigate. It handles designer items efficiently, making it a reliable spot for consigning staple pieces.

Vintage designer pieces stand out with brands like Gaultier, Westwood, Supreme, and Balenciaga. The store has a busy thrift atmosphere and a scrap metal Predator storefront that adds to its cool vibe.

People are saying

"I always found cool, dope, random pieces here."

"This thrift store has a curated selection of luxury and vintage designer pieces."

"This high-end consignment shop is filled with curated grails and quality garments."

Good to know

1

You can only try on 3 items at a time.

2

The consignment process at Tokio 7 is straightforward.

3

The store has a uniquely curated selection of designer, vintage, and archive fashion pieces.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...