Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for PB&J paired with chocolate chip cookies in New York City

Based on 159 Reviews
+156
User
User
User
Updated
01
Daytime image 1
Daytime image 2
Daytime image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿ›‹๏ธ Cozy
๐Ÿฅ Croissant
More

Cozy cafe on a quiet side street offers limited seating with sunlit windows filled with plants. The atmosphere is chill and neighborly, though music can be loud for the small space. Frequent crowds form on weekday mornings, creating a lively but tight environment.

People are saying

"I love the chill vibe and great coffee here."

"The sandwiches here are always tasty and fresh."

Good to know

1

Parking in the area is generally a nightmare.

2

The line is generally long and moves slowly.

3

The seating is insufficient at the location.

02
787 Coffee image 1
787 Coffee image 2
787 Coffee image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿ˜Ž Chill
๐Ÿ›‹๏ธ Cozy
More

Coffee shop offers natural light, plants, and varied seating for working or relaxing. Atmosphere combines welcoming decor with a curated playlist and occasional acoustic acts. Patrons engage with unique touches like writing gratitude notes on coffee filters, creating a distinct community vibe.

People are saying

"The chocolate chip cookies here are warm, soft, and delicious."

"The chocolate chip cookies are super tasty and filling."

"The chicken empanadas and chocolate chip cookies go great together."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop closes at 7PM.

2

Expect live music events regularly throughout the month.

3

Discounts are available for healthcare workers.

03
Bub's Bakery image 1
Bub's Bakery image 2
Bub's Bakery image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿฅœ Nut-Free Diet
๐Ÿฅ— Vegetarian
More

Bright space with yellow color and cozy seating creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. All baked goods are free of common allergens, catering especially to those with dietary restrictions. The bakery offers soft, flavorful gluten-free pastries that stand out in quality and taste.

People are saying

"I love that their allergen-free treats taste amazing."

"The cinnamon roll here is absolutely the best."

Good to know

1

Bub's Bakery opens at 7 am, but pastries are ready closer to 8 am.

2

All baked goods are free of nuts, gluten, dairy, eggs, and soy.

3

Expect a limited selection later in the day as items sell out.

04
Haniโ€™s bakery + cafรฉ image 1
Haniโ€™s bakery + cafรฉ image 2
Haniโ€™s bakery + cafรฉ image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿซ Hot Chocolate
๐ŸŽ‚ Cheesecake
More

Long, narrow space with minimalist design and thoughtful details creates a warm, cozy atmosphere despite limited seating. Busy and popular, it offers counter seating where people watch pastry making, adding to the inviting vibe. Dog-friendly touches and outdoor seating extend the welcoming feel.

People are saying

"These chocolate chip cookies have a perfect salty-sweet balance."

"The chocolate chip cookie is soft, rich, and sweet."

"Some loved the peanut butter and jelly cake, others found it lacking."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait for a seat on weekends due to high demand.

2

Seating is limited, and most customers opt for takeout.

3

The price for three pastries is around $40.

05
Insomnia Cookies image 1
Insomnia Cookies image 2
Insomnia Cookies image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐ŸŒ™ Late Night Spot
๐Ÿช Cookie
More

Cookie shop inside a transit hub offers fresh, hot cookies with popular vegan options and quick service despite occasional long lines. The space lacks seating and feels lively with a busy, urban vibe. Customers find the cookies delicious but note some inconsistency in texture and pricing.

People are saying

"I really enjoyed the cookies and the whole vibe."

"I love their amazing gluten-free chocolate chip cookie option."

"The chocolate chip cookie tastes amazing."

Good to know

1

The line usually has a wait of 2-10 minutes.

2

A 6 pack of cookies costs around $17.

3

They offer a gluten free option for chocolate chip cookies.

06
Burger & Shake Co. image 1
Burger & Shake Co. image 2
Burger & Shake Co. image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฅช Chicken Sandwich
๐Ÿท๏ธ Affordable
More

Hamburger restaurant offers an easy-going atmosphere with a wall-length cooler stocked with dozens of beers and affordable prices. The space feels lively and neighborhood-y, attracting many students and families. Pinball machine adds a playful touch to the casual vibe.

People are saying

"The burgers and fries taste great and feel fresh."

"The place feels chill and the prices are right."

"The corn dogs are huge, crispy, and super tasty."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $12 for a burger and fries combo for pickup.

2

The business closes at 7pm every day.

3

The wait time can be long during busy hours.

07
Chip City image 1
Chip City image 2
Chip City image 3
View all
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฅฃ Oatmeal
๐Ÿช Cookies And Cream
More

Warm, sweet atmosphere fills a clean, cute space with soft, chewy cookies that stand out for their original flavors and freshly baked quality. Variety includes dairy-free options and multiple milk choices, catering to different tastes and allergies. Small grab-and-go setups often sit near parks, inviting casual enjoyment outdoors.

People are saying

"The cookies were warm, soft, and absolutely delicious."

"I loved the cozy vibe and friendly feel of the place."

"The triple chocolate chip cookie was an explosion of joy."

Good to know

1

Each cookie costs about $5.

2

There is a promotion of buy 5 get 1 free.

3

The shop offers dairy free options.

08
Piece-A-Cake image 1
Piece-A-Cake image 2
Piece-A-Cake image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿฅ Pastry
๐Ÿฅฎ Brownie
More

Spacious cafe filled with unique antiques and nostalgic decor inspired by historic New York scenes. Atmosphere is cozy and lively, often bustling with families and children running around. Displays showcase a wide variety of cakes and pastries, creating a sweet and inviting environment.

People are saying

"I love their cookies, tarts, and pastries the most."

"The eclairs have gotten smaller and less creamy lately."

Good to know

1

Street parking is the only option available.

2

The prices for an average size coffee are around 6 or 7 dollars.

3

Ordering online is a better experience than showing up in person for breakfast.

09
Red Gate Bakery image 1
Red Gate Bakery image 2
Red Gate Bakery image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿฅฎ Brownie
๐Ÿช Blondies
More

Small shop with cozy, nostalgic atmosphere and fresh baked cookie aroma. Bakers work visibly behind the counter, creating an intimate, welcoming vibe. Limited indoor space with only one small outdoor table emphasizes its charming, boutique feel.

People are saying

"These chocolate chip cookies are exceptionally good and chewy."

"I'd buy the cinnamon bun again; it was worth it."

"The toffee chocolate chip cookie divides opinions."

Good to know

1

The cookie shop opens at 11 AM.

2

They sell out quickly, so arrive early.

3

Red Gate is not open late.

10
Hamburger America image 1
Hamburger America image 2
Hamburger America image 3
View all
๐Ÿช Chocolate Chip Cookies
๐Ÿฅœ Peanut Butter And Jelly
๐Ÿ•น๏ธ Retro
๐Ÿ’ญ Nostalgic
More

Vintage burger diner with retro-modern design and old school American vibe fills a small space packed with eager diners. Formica counters and sizzling flattops create a nostalgic atmosphere where the burger assembly line is visible from the counter. Outdoor seating and a bar add variety to the lively, crowded setting.

People are saying

"The classic smash and fried onion burgers really hit the spot."

"It gets busy, but the foodโ€™s quick and prices are fair."

"I thought the burger and fries were spectacular."

Good to know

1

You order food and pay upfront, which makes the process easy and efficient.

2

Be warned that lines can be long on certain days at George Motzโ€™s restaurant.

3

Opening time is the best time to visit to avoid crowds.