Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for New York-style pizza for casual dates in New York City

Based on 874 Reviews
+871
User
User
User
Updated
01
Pop’s Pizza of East Village image 1
Pop’s Pizza of East Village image 2
Pop’s Pizza of East Village image 3
View all
🤙 Casual Dates
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🍕 Pizza
🍞 Sourdough
More

Small pizza shop with a cozy, homey atmosphere and laid-back decor creates a warm, inviting vibe. Friendly energy reflects the community spirit of the neighborhood. Known for exceptional pizza, made with a careful fermentation process, it draws a steady crowd seeking quality and comfort.

People are saying

"The pizza has fresh cheese and a crispy crust."

"I always come back because the pizza is great."

"I experienced classic New York Style Pizza that reminded me of how it used to taste."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria is dog-friendly, allowing pets on the outdoor patio.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

3

Parking is limited; consider using public transport or rideshare services.

02
Decades Pizza | Bar and Restaurant in Ridgewood, Queens - NYC image 1
Decades Pizza | Bar and Restaurant in Ridgewood, Queens - NYC image 2
Decades Pizza | Bar and Restaurant in Ridgewood, Queens - NYC image 3
View all
🤙 Casual Dates
🍕 New York Style Pizza
💘 Date Spots
🍞 Sourdough
More

Glass doors on pizza ovens reveal pies cooking in a cozy, beautifully decorated space with bright lighting and no TVs. The atmosphere feels friendly and romantic, with a perfect playlist setting a casual, welcoming vibe. It attracts a neighborhood crowd that values quality and a relaxed pace.

People are saying

"I love the unique flavors and lively vibe here."

"Their Caesar salad is the best I've ever had."

"I loved the classic New York style pizza with a doughy and crispy crust."

Good to know

1

Happy hour starts at 5 PM.

2

The square slices are only available from 5-7 PM during weekday happy hours.

3

It is strongly recommended to get a reservation ahead, especially after 7pm on weekends.

03
Upside Pizza image 1
Upside Pizza image 2
Upside Pizza image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🤙 Casual Dates
🍞 Sourdough
🍕 Pizza
More

Shiny, new pizza spot with classic New York charm and loud techno music creating a lively but intense atmosphere. Pizza features crispy chewy crusts and standout spicy vodka sauce, though slices tend to be small and greasy. Outdoor seating is available but requires some upkeep.

Good to know

1

Slices cost $5 each, which may be considered expensive by some.

2

There was no line at the pizzeria during my visit.

3

Upside Pizza is convenient for students looking for a quick meal.

04
Kingsbridge Social Club image 1
Kingsbridge Social Club image 2
Kingsbridge Social Club image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🤙 Casual Dates
🦑 Calamari
🥪 Chicken Sandwich
More

Small Italian restaurant offers a cozy patio and friendly bar with a neighborhood vibe. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, making it easy to settle in. Affordable prices and quality pizza stand out as key draws.

People are saying

"I loved the great food and fun vibe here."

"The pizzas and dishes were delicious and well made."

"The drinks and craft beers were really enjoyable."

Good to know

1

They have a 'make your own pizza' special on Mondays.

2

Happy hour deals are available daily from 4-6pm.

3

The date night deal includes pizza, salad, dessert, and a bottle of wine for $50.

05
Louie's image 1
Louie's image 2
Louie's image 3
View all
🤙 Casual Dates
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🥩 Ribeye Steak
📻 Vintage
More

Small space with vintage style decor and diner-like seating creates an old school New York pizzeria vibe. Atmosphere feels friendly and down-to-earth, offering an intimate and welcoming setting. Regulars enjoy a comfortable, urban environment that feels like home.

People are saying

"I love their pizza and respect their courage."

"I dreamed of the grandma slice; it's the best New York Style Pizza I've ever had."

"I love how the crust tastes just like real New York pizza."

Good to know

1

Prices can be high, with three large pizzas costing around $67.

2

Cash payments are preferred; credit cards may be accepted.

3

The pizza place is known for high-quality ingredients.

06
Patsy's Pizzeria image 1
Patsy's Pizzeria image 2
Patsy's Pizzeria image 3
View all
🤙 Casual Dates
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🛋️ Cozy
🍕 Pizza
More

Spacious dining room with quaint seating and nostalgic decor creates a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. Music varies from Caribbean vibes to festive tunes, contributing to a generally quiet and relaxed mood. Known for exceptional pizza, the place draws those seeking classic Italian flavors in a charming setting.

People are saying

"I really enjoyed the fresh pizza and pasta here."

"The pizza had a great crust and tasty sauce."

"I found the New York style pizza to be tasty."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; walk-ins are welcome.

2

The restaurant opens at 11:30 AM, not 11 AM as stated online.

3

Patsy's Pizzeria does not serve pizza by the slice, only whole pies.

07
Joe & Pat's NYC image 1
Joe & Pat's NYC image 2
Joe & Pat's NYC image 3
View all
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🤙 Casual Dates
🍕 Thin Crust Pizza
💘 Date Spots
More

Vintage pizzeria offers classic thin crust New York style pizza with a cozy, old-school vibe. Romantic lighting and a covered patio create a relaxed setting perfect for casual dates. Loud music and wooden tables add to the inviting atmosphere.

People are saying

"I love the thin, crunchy crust and fresh toppings."

"I love how authentic the New York style pizza tastes here."

"It's great to find a good sit-down place for New York style pizza."

Good to know

1

Happy hour on weekdays from 4-7 PM offers reduced prices on drinks and small pizzas.

2

You must request the happy hour menu to access the deals.

3

The happy hour deal for vodka pizza is $12.

08
BRAVO PIZZA image 1
BRAVO PIZZA image 2
BRAVO PIZZA image 3
View all
🤙 Casual Dates
🍕 New York Style Pizza
🇮🇹 Italian Food
👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Kid Friendly
More

Spacious and clean dining area offers a warm and inviting atmosphere with cozy nooks and excellent music. The vibe stays calm and relaxing, welcoming groups and families comfortably. Pizza here is fresh and delicious, often praised as some of the best in the city.

People are saying

"The pizza here is always fresh and delicious."

"I think this place serves the best pizza around."

"I experienced the best traditional New York Style Pizza."

Good to know

1

The price of a cheese slice is $3.67.

2

Customers are allowed to bring dogs while ordering.

3

The restaurant serves great slices late at night.