Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for caramel and cherry pie to enjoy in New York City

Based on 690 Reviews
+687
User
User
User
Updated
01
Bartleby & Sage image 1
Bartleby & Sage image 2
Bartleby & Sage image 3
View all
🍯 Caramel
🥧 Cherry Pie
🍽️ Dinner Spots
🐟 Salmon
More

Catering service delivers an elevated aesthetic with attention to detail that transforms tight spaces into stunning venues. The atmosphere feels warm and elegant, with smooth operations that accommodate diverse dietary needs and create memorable events.

Good to know

1

Bartleby & Sage offers customizable menus to fit various dietary preferences.

2

They can cater events for up to 400 guests with multiple meal options.

3

Expect a seamless event execution with no lines at the bar.

02
Wyckoff Starr Coffee Shop image 1
Wyckoff Starr Coffee Shop image 2
Wyckoff Starr Coffee Shop image 3
View all
🍯 Caramel
🥧 Cherry Pie
🛋️ Cozy
Cafe
More

Small coffee shop with an intimate, cozy atmosphere inspired by Twin Peaks and David Lynch. Music selections are eclectic and never repeated, creating a unique vibe. Limited seating encourages a grab-and-go experience with affordable prices and artsy decor.

People are saying

"The music’s always fresh and the coffee’s great."

"It’s a cozy spot with a cool Twin Peaks vibe."

"They’ve got tasty drinks and baked goods to try."

Good to know

1

It is recommended to get things to-go in case you don't get a seat.

2

There is not much seating at the cafe.

3

I recommend bringing cash to take advantage of the discount.

03
Cookies and Cream Pastry Shop image 1
Cookies and Cream Pastry Shop image 2
Cookies and Cream Pastry Shop image 3
View all
🥧 Cherry Pie
🍯 Caramel
🍰 Chocolate Cake
🥐 Pastry
More

Small pastry shop offers a cozy atmosphere with cute outdoor seating and a warm vibe. Pastries are high quality and reasonably priced, with standout items like rich muffins and custom cakes. The space feels inviting for casual visits with friends or family.

People are saying

"The pastries and cakes here taste amazing and fresh."

"Everything I got was fresh, delicious, and well priced."

"Diana made the perfect cake and was great to work with."

Good to know

1

Reservations for custom cakes require at least two weeks' notice.

2

Pricing for cakes, cupcakes, and cookies is very reasonable.

3

Customer service can vary; visiting early may improve your experience.

04
Avenue Bakery NYC image 1
Avenue Bakery NYC image 2
Avenue Bakery NYC image 3
View all
🥧 Cherry Pie
🍯 Caramel
🍫 Hot Chocolate
🏘️ Local Spot
More

Spacious bakery with an inconspicuous entrance leading to a cozy back lounge featuring a fireplace and comfortable seating. Bright, clean interior combines a family-friendly atmosphere with a quiet spot for work or conversation. Displays showcase a wide variety of Kosher-certified pastries and desserts.

People are saying

"I love their wide range of tasty cakes and treats."

"I was let down by the fake giveaways and no free treats."

Good to know

1

Customers cannot eat food in the dining area because the tables are wait-service only.

2

There is no seating available currently.

3

The bakery is clean and kosher.

05
Four & Twenty Blackbirds image 1
Four & Twenty Blackbirds image 2
Four & Twenty Blackbirds image 3
View all
🥧 Cherry Pie
🍯 Caramel
🥧 Pie
🍫 Chocolate
More

Pie shop offers cozy, rustic interior with spacious wooden tables and charging outlets for seating. Atmosphere stays quiet and chill, ideal for enjoying high-quality pies and strong coffee. Small space fills up during peak times but maintains a friendly, welcoming vibe.

People are saying

"The pies here are always delicious and unique."

"I can't get enough of the salted caramel apple pie."

"I love how the pies are packed with apples and caramel."

Good to know

1

Order your pie extra early for Thanksgiving as they will sell out.

2

The price for a slice of pie is $6.00.

3

The price for a whole pie is about $45.

06
The Dutch image 1
The Dutch image 2
The Dutch image 3
View all
🥧 Cherry Pie
🍯 Caramel
🥧 Pie
🍳 Eggs
More

Lively Soho spot offers covered sidewalk tables and a private dining room for varied vibes. Desserts shine with caramel-drizzled coconut cake and a sour cherry pie with crispy shell and ice cream. Bar wraps around center, blending indoor and outdoor charm.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and carefully prepared."

"I’m definitely coming back soon for another visit."

"The lobster roll had too little lobster for the price."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed for brunch to ensure a table.

2

Brunch time is a popular time to visit, expect crowds.

3

The price of a glass of white wine is $19.

07
Budapest cafe image 1
Budapest cafe image 2
Budapest cafe image 3
View all
🥧 Cherry Pie
🍯 Caramel
🥧 Pie
🥐 Rugelach
More

Small space with brickface design and vintage accents creates a calm, nostalgic atmosphere. Pastry display features golden pastries and delicate tarts that draw attention. Quiet and cozy setting invites slow conversations and intimate dining.

People are saying

"The food feels authentic with tasty pastries and dishes."

"The cafe feels cozy but has lost some charm lately."

Good to know

1

Customers have to wait until 11:00 am to order lunch.

2

You should arrive early if you want any chance at a seat.

3

They run out of sweet treats by the end of the day.

08
Skirt Steak image 1
Skirt Steak image 2
Skirt Steak image 3
View all
🍯 Caramel
🥧 Cherry Pie
🤙 Casual
😎 Cool
More

Woodwork and Scandinavian design create a calm, stylish setting with a rolling dessert cart adding a unique touch. The atmosphere ranges from relaxing to warm and lively near the bar. Long waits are common due to no reservations and high demand.

People are saying

"The steak and food here taste really good."

"The unlimited fries are tasty and crispy."

"I’m planning to come back despite the wait."

Good to know

1

If you like french fries, it's all you can eat.

2

Dessert is offered via a cart at $10 after the entree is finished.

3

The restaurant does not take reservations unless for a party of 7+.