Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice

Top 10 spots for authentic vanilla milkshakes to Enjoy in New York City

Based on 825 Reviews
+822
User
User
User
Updated
01
Complete Cafe, LLC image 1
Complete Cafe, LLC image 2
Complete Cafe, LLC image 3
View all
🎯 Authentic
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🎉 Fun Activities
🛋️ Cozy
More

Interactive tables with touch screens and puzzles create a playful dining experience. Bright, spacious interiors include a large indoor playground with slides and climbing walls, making it ideal for families. Outdoor seating offers a cozy atmosphere surrounded by greenery and stunning views.

People are saying

"The interactive tables and play areas make it a fun spot for families."

"I will definitely come back here soon."

Good to know

1

The Complete indoor playground is the largest in Manhattan.

2

The restaurant offers healthy food options for both kids and adults.

3

The indoor playground is safe, spacious, and filled with creative play areas for kids.

02
Cubby's image 1
Cubby's image 2
Cubby's image 3
View all
🎯 Authentic
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🍔 Veggie Burger
🍟 Sweet Potato Fries
More

Small hamburger restaurant offers a warm, fun atmosphere with non-screen tabletop games that engage all ages. Clean, open space features marble counters and nostalgic decor with a youthful twist. Burgers stand out as a distinctive culinary highlight in the city.

People are saying

"The burgers and shakes here taste fantastic."

"The onion rings are crispy and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

You need to pay cash to avoid the credit card fee.

2

Cubby's has a deal for Beacon students: burger, fries, soda, and ice cream for $15.

3

Take out is available for those on the go.

03
Tria Bakery Cafe Diner image 1
Tria Bakery Cafe Diner image 2
Tria Bakery Cafe Diner image 3
View all
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🎯 Authentic
🍟 Diner
🍫 Chocolate
More

Classic diner space with American-themed decor and an older TV adds a nostalgic touch. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, blending modern cleanliness with a relaxed, friendly vibe. Small bakery section offers an impressive pastry selection that stands out.

People are saying

"I love the fresh and affordable breakfast here."

"The food is fresh, cooked well, and filling."

"The orange juice tastes really fresh."

Good to know

1

The diner is completely wheelchair accessible.

2

Coffee is free with any meal.

3

The prices at the diner are quite reasonable for Manhattan.

04
La Churreria image 1
La Churreria image 2
La Churreria image 3
View all
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🎯 Authentic
🛋️ Cozy
🍯 Dulce De Leche
More

Small indoor space seats about 10 with an outdoor table, creating an intimate and cozy setting. Warm, welcoming vibe with great music and seasonal decorations adds charm. Known for authentic churros and fun atmosphere, though seating can feel cramped and busy.

People are saying

"The churros and desserts taste fresh and authentic."

"I loved the place and can't wait to come back."

"The prices felt a bit high for what I got."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait for a table, especially during busy hours.

2

Get there early if you plan on dining in, as seating is limited.

3

They offer 5 churros for $4.50, a great deal for a sweet treat.

05
Mike's Coffee Shop image 1
Mike's Coffee Shop image 2
Mike's Coffee Shop image 3
View all
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🎯 Authentic
🏷️ Cheap
📻 Vintage
More

Classic diner with old school atmosphere and friendly service offers counter and booth seating in a bright, vibrant space. Regulars create a steady, welcoming vibe ideal for solo dining or small groups. Bottomless coffee and outdoor tables add to the laid-back, no-frills experience.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and classic breakfast here."

"The pancakes here are the best around."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait a bit when the diner is busy.

2

The diner is cash only; there is an in-house ATM.

3

Expect a packed house during peak hours.

06
Bareburger image 1
Bareburger image 2
Bareburger image 3
View all
🎯 Authentic
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🥘 Food
🍟 Sweet Potato Fries
More

Big, artsy space with cozy booths and appealing decor creates a family-friendly, relaxed atmosphere. Complimentary popcorn and gluten-free options cater to diverse needs, while cocktail variety includes standout margaritas and unique beers on tap.

People are saying

"The burgers and food taste amazing."

"Wellington made us feel welcome and cared for."

"I always have a great time with awesome food and service."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $3 Moscow mules from 12pm to 7pm daily.

2

Happy hour on Saturdays features 50% off margaritas.

3

Sundaes are only a dollar on Sunday.

07
Bareburger image 1
Bareburger image 2
Bareburger image 3
View all
🎯 Authentic
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🍗 Fried Chicken Sandwich
🥪 Chicken Sandwich
More

Hamburger restaurant offers a spacious, well-furnished setting with an eclectic music selection that creates a lively atmosphere. Comfortable seating and outdoor dining with heaters add to the inviting vibe. The menu includes keto buns and vegan options, appealing to diverse tastes.

People are saying

"The burgers and fries taste amazing and satisfying."

"I highly recommend their guacamole fries and hot sauce."

"I love coming here for the great food and options."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 12pm to 7pm with $1 pints of PBR.

2

Happy hour offers beer and cocktails at half price.

3

Reservations are recommended to secure a table, especially during peak hours.

08
Black Iron Burger Theater District | Hamburger restaurant Bar image 1
Black Iron Burger Theater District | Hamburger restaurant Bar image 2
Black Iron Burger Theater District | Hamburger restaurant Bar image 3
View all
🎯 Authentic
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🍔 Burgers
🤙 Casual
More

Spacious sports bar with plentiful screens showing live games and a lively atmosphere fueled by harmonious music and enthusiastic fans. The bar area offers a social spot for drinks, featuring a top-tier playlist blending 80s rock and pop. The vibe balances energetic and chill, making it a popular hangout for sports enthusiasts.

People are saying

"These authentic American burgers are the best I've ever had."

"I love the authentic American burgers here."

"The vibe is authentic and laid-back."

Good to know

1

Happy hour beers are available until 7 PM for 6 euros.

2

The restaurant has a happy hour every day with great specials.

3

The restaurant can get very crowded after shows, so arrive early.

09
Hershey's Chocolate World image 1
Hershey's Chocolate World image 2
Hershey's Chocolate World image 3
View all
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🎯 Authentic
😎 Cool
🎉 Fun Activities
More

Chocolate shop offers an immersive sensory experience with an overwhelming smell of sugar and chocolate. Colorful, fun decor and interactive displays create a lively, crowded atmosphere. Unique features include custom candy bar wrappers and a stuff your own cup-Reese's bar.

People are saying

"I love the wide selection of tasty chocolates here."

"They always greet me with free chocolate samples."

"It's a fun chocolate spot right in Times Square."

Good to know

1

Hershey's central location in Times Square makes it easily accessible.

2

The establishment only accepts plastic payments.

3

There are no restrooms available for anyone, including paying customers.

10
Bareburger image 1
Bareburger image 2
Bareburger image 3
View all
🎯 Authentic
🥤 Vanilla Milkshake
🍔 Hamburger
🍔 Burgers
More

Small space offers a cozy, family-friendly vibe with chic decor and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Music plays softly, creating a relaxed energy. A bar serves gluten-free and affordable beers, complementing the handcrafted burgers and sliders.

People are saying

"The burgers here are some of the best I've had."

"I loved the cozy vibe and tasty food here."

"I always have a great time with amazing food and service."

Good to know

1

The $1 PBR happy hour is from 12-7 PM, Monday to Friday.

2

The restaurant offers a BOGO Taco Tuesday deal.

3

They have specials during the week, including tacos on Tuesdays and ice cream sundaes on Sundays.